We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience and deliver our services. By continuing to visit this site, you agree to our use of cookies.More info
The Annie Clougherty TeamThe Annie Clougherty Team
  • Our Team
  • Our Services
  • Client Success
Get In Touch

Who We Are

  • Our Team
  • Client Success
  • Blog
  • Press & Media

Buying and Selling

  • Seller Services
  • Previously Sold
  • Buyer Services
  • Find Your Dream Home
  • Mortgage Calculator

The Annie Clougherty Team

341 Bayside Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660

  • 949-375-3037
  • [email protected]

What you sacrifice when you hire a discount broker and why you should pay a full commission

Allow me to present a story that not only revolves around commission but also delves into the essence of my work and the...

  • Annie Clougherty
  • July 2nd, 2023
  • 4 min read
Featured Image
Allow me to present a story that not only revolves around commission but also delves into the essence of my work and the value that I bring to the table. It is a testament to the fact that real estate agents are worth their commission as they have the skills, knowledge, and expertise to handle complex situations that may arise during a real estate transaction. It is also a reminder that sometimes, agents may have to negotiate their commission rates, but in the end, their value and hard work shine through.

 

 

In July of 2022, I had a meeting with a homeowner in Mission Viejo who wanted to sell his property. He had purchased the house less than a year ago and had already moved out due to dissatisfaction with the neighborhood. He had started some renovation projects in the home but had not been able to complete them. He reached out to me to see if I could help him finish the work before putting the property on the market. However, he also requested that I reduce my commission to 1.5%, which was lower than my usual fee of 2.5%.

 

I explained to him that I would not be able to reduce my commission if he wanted me and my team to handle the remodel using our vendors. He argued that other online brokers and vendors could manage the job for him, but I emphasized the superior quality of my individual stats and marketing compared to other agents. After a few weeks, the homeowner contacted me and agreed to hire my team. We began working on the property with our vendors by completing the paint job, installing new carpeting, finishing the laundry room, building a new closet, and replacing the master vanity. We also staged the house and put it on the market.

 

Unfortunately, the market in that particular neighborhood took a downturn, and all sales came to a halt. We listed the property at a higher price than what we should have initially, and it remained unsold for a long time. Despite multiple open houses, we received few offers, and the homeowner was unwilling to accept any of them. This cycle of marketing, showing, and hosting open houses continued for several months until we finally received an offer that the homeowner agreed upon.

 

However, another obstacle emerged when the buyer conducted an inspection on the property. The inspection revealed that the roof had many broken tiles and that the roofing material was discontinued, with a class-action lawsuit against it. We could not find any roofing company willing to undertake the repairs, and we were unable to obtain the necessary roofing material. As a result, the entire roof needed to be replaced.

 

Given the already high price of the property, which was higher than the other comps in the area, the homeowner's resistance to lower it, and the property's lengthy time on the market, we had a difficult situation on our hands. Nonetheless, I decided to negotiate with everyone involved and work towards a satisfactory outcome. We all agreed to contribute a portion to a credit for the roof repair, with myself, the buyer's agent, and the homeowner and the buyer sharing the burden.

 

Many agents may not discuss such issues, and some may even refuse to offer any credits. However, in my experience, it is sometimes necessary to make tough business decisions and negotiate commission rates based on those decisions. If I had negotiated my commission down in the beginning, I would not have been able to step in and offer a credit. In the end, even if this particular property was not profitable for me and after months of work, I would consider it a loss, but, the satisfaction of a happy homeowner and a pleased buyer made it all worth it. And with Maritza Bernard's assistance, we walked away with another satisfied client, regardless of the profit or loss.

 

This story illustrates that real estate transactions can be unpredictable and often involve unexpected challenges.

 

 

Author Photo
About the author

Annie Clougherty

  • facebook
  • X
  • instagram
  • linkedin
  • youtube
949-375-3037
[email protected]
With over 20 years of experience, Annie Clougherty has built a reputation as one of the top real estate agents in Orange County, California, and nationwide. Representing both buyers and sellers, Annie’s expertise spans across coastal Orange County, where her deep understanding of the community and market trends sets her apart. Recognized by both her peers and industry leaders, Annie has been listed as one of the top agents in the country by the Wall Street Journal’s “Real Trends” report, ranking in the Top 1½% of agents nationwide for sales volume from 2019 to 2024. She has also consistently been ranked among the top 100 real estate agents in California. Joining Compass in its early days, Annie has been a part of its growth from 2,200 agents to over 30,000 nationwide. This network gives her unparalleled resources and connections, benefiting her clients at every stage of their real estate journey. Annie’s strategic approach, honed through years of navigating competitive markets, ensures her clients achieve the best outcomes. Whether marketing high-end properties in Newport Coast or negotiating contingent offers, her professionalism and dedication shine. Beyond real estate, Annie stays active in her community. From participating in the Newport Beach Distinguished Citizens Program to raising funds through events like Air Band, she values giving back and strengthening community ties. Annie Clougherty combines local expertise, a nationwide network, and a proven track record of excellence to deliver exceptional results for her clients.
With over 20 years of experience, Annie Clougherty has built a reputation as one of the top real estate agents in Orange County, California, and nationwide. Representing both buyers and sellers, Annie’s expertise spans across coastal Orange County, where her deep understanding of the community and market trends sets her apart. Recognized by both her peers and industry leaders, Annie has been listed as one of the top agents in the country by the Wall Street Journal’s “Real Trends” report, ranking in the Top 1½% of agents nationwide for sales volume from 2019 to 2024. She has also consistently been ranked among the top 100 real estate agents in California. Joining Compass in its early days, Annie has been a part of its growth from 2,200 agents to over 30,000 nationwide. This network gives her unparalleled resources and connections, benefiting her clients at every stage of their real estate journey. Annie’s strategic approach, honed through years of navigating competitive markets, ensures her clients achieve the best outcomes. Whether marketing high-end properties in Newport Coast or negotiating contingent offers, her professionalism and dedication shine. Beyond real estate, Annie stays active in her community. From participating in the Newport Beach Distinguished Citizens Program to raising funds through events like Air Band, she values giving back and strengthening community ties. Annie Clougherty combines local expertise, a nationwide network, and a proven track record of excellence to deliver exceptional results for her clients.

Similar posts like this

Some of The Most Expensive Real Estate in Newport Harbor

Let’s talk about the Turning Basin in Newport Harbor. There are many beautiful homes on the Harbor, but some of the most...

Read more

Building a Legacy Through Smart Real Estate Moves in Newport 

You have heard this before; location, location, location and another one is, buy real estate and hold. I have a very savvy...

Read more

The Real Housewives Dock You’ll Definitely Be Seeing Again

Any Real Housewives of Orange County fans out there? As I was watching this episode, yes, I watch it, I noticed the ladies...

Read more
The Annie Clougherty Team

Reputation. Dedication. Community. Communication. Tenacity. Results. 24/7.

The Annie Clougherty Team | DRE# 01716801

341 Bayside Drive, Newport Beach, CA 92660

  • 949-375-3037
  • [email protected]
Join Our Email List!

*We respect your inbox. We only send interesting and relevant emails.

The Annie Clougherty Team | DRE# 01716801 © 2025

Privacy Policy
Powered by